Fantasy Puzzles

Shop by Category

Toys & Hobbies
- Puzzles
- Contemporary Puzzles
- Vintage Puzzles

629 Results

Foil Effect Metallic 500 Piece Puzzle Girl Eagles Camels Butterflies MC Puzzle
$17.00
or Best Offer
$6.34 shipping
HARRY POTTER PUZZLE 400PC "THE GREAT HALL"
$19.99
$11.40 shipping
1987 Springbok Hallmark Puzzle "Monsters and Mystery" 100 pcs / PZL1207 Complete
$50.00
or Best Offer
$7.34 shipping
Vtg Puzzle Springbok Island Fantasy 500 Pc Sealed 18"x 24" Ocean Sailboat Palms
$29.00
or Best Offer
$9.45 shipping
1982 Springbok Song Of The Unicorn Puzzle *Missing 1 Piece* Hallmark PZL4143
$29.95
or Best Offer
$6.51 shipping
Vintage Springbok Carnival of Harlequin Puzzle 390 pieces COMPLETE + Poster Miro
$125.00
or Best Offer
$7.16 shipping
Vintage 1977 Springbok “Verticalville” 500 Piece Puzzle - MISSING 1 PIECE
$44.00
or Best Offer
$11.40 shipping
Dungeons & Dragons 300 Piece 18" x 24" Jigsaw Puzzle Yawning Portal Gencon
$11.99
$10.65 shipping
Vintage Round Springbok Puzzle - Five-Clawed Dragon - 390 pieces COMPLETE
$112.00
or Best Offer
$9.63 shipping
Vintage Springbok 500 Piece Puzzle Song of The Unicorn Vtg 1970'S
$21.95
or Best Offer
$7.67 shipping
Vintage Springbok Thingie Jigsaw Puzzle 1968 Family Portrait PZL9001 Sealed
$45.00
$7.67 shipping
Wrebbit 3D Puzzle Harry Potter Ford Anglia NEW Limited Edition 24 Piece Kids
(2)
$3.90
Was: $5.00was - US $5.00
$4.68 shipping
Springbok Hallmark Puzzle COMPLETE At the Wee Folks Fair 1000 Piece 24x30" VTG
$45.00
or Best Offer
$7.28 shipping
Red Dragonfly Foil Fantasy Bug 500 PC Puzzle Milton Bradley 2019 Metallic Effect
$10.89
$5.99 shipping
Harry Potter 3D puzzles lot of 2 Great Hall and Astronomy Tower Sealed No Box
$47.50
or Best Offer
$10.12 shipping
Vtg Springbok Light Fantasy Puzzle 500 P 1973 USA circular Photo Art 505 Pcs!
$34.99
or Best Offer
$6.90 shipping
New England Fantasy, Vintage Springbok Puzzle, 1000 pieces, 1984, complete
$14.00
or Best Offer
$12.30 shipping
0 bids
17h 23m
Springbok BUCCANEER'S DREAM 500 pc Jigsaw Puzzle PZL4414 Complete MERMAID Ocean
$42.95
$8.41 shipping
Vintage Springbok 500 Piece Puzzle Song of The Unicorn Vtg 1970'S
$25.00
or Best Offer
$12.00 shipping
Lord of the Rings Wrebbit Hobbiton 3D Puzzle 363 pcs The Hobbit An Unexpected Jo
(1)
$120.00
or Best Offer
$6.34 shipping
3 watching
THE LORD of the RINGS THE TWO TOWERS ORTHANC TOWER Puzz 3D Puzzle 350 UNCOUNTED
$36.99
Free shipping
Lord of the Rings Wrebbit Citadel of Minas Tirith 3D Puzzle 819 pcs Over 2' High
$160.00
or Best Offer
$6.65 shipping
Vintage Springbok Jigsaw Puzzle LUMINESCENCE! 500+ pc Octagonal Shaped COMPLETE
$100.00
or Best Offer
$14.40 shipping
Vtg 1984 Springbok 500pc octagonal shaped jigsaw puzzle Luminescence! COMPLETE
$91.00
or Best Offer
$10.50 shipping
🧩🌻 NIS - Witches Gathering 500pcs Springbok Puzzle 🌻🧩
$16.95
$7.96 shipping
2 watching
Wrebbit 3D - Harry Potter Hogwarts Great Hall 3D Jigsaw Puzzle - 850Piece Sealed
(12)
$18.49
$11.40 shipping
VTG Springbok Puzzle, New England Fantasy, embroidery 1000pc COMPLETE!
$10.00
or Best Offer
$8.58 shipping
Vtg 1973 Jigsaw Puzzle Walt Disney's Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs Pzl-1081
$8.99
or Best Offer
$9.91 shipping
SEALED 2003 Neopets 100-Piece Puzzle Lupe Warrior Hasbro MB
$15.00
$8.00 shipping
NEW Vintage Springbok "At the Wee Folks Fair" 1000 Piece King-Size Jigsaw Puzzle
$99.99
Free shipping
Vtg 1979 Springbok MOUNTAINSIDE PARK Bob Martin 1000 Pc Jigsaw Puzzle
$23.98
$19.60 shipping
HTF Vintage 1977 Hallmark Jigsaw Puzzle Story Search for the Flying Saucer 110
$39.95
or Best Offer
$7.99 shipping
Opened Wrebbit The Lord of the Rings - Golden Hall - Edoras 3D Puzzle: 445 Pcs
(1)
$29.99
$7.99 shipping
Fantasyland, Vintage Springbok children's puzzle, 100 pieces, complete
$18.00
or Best Offer
$9.00 shipping
0 bids
15h 26m
The Lord of the Rings Wrebbit Rohan The Two Towers Puzzle 500 pcs Perfalock
$70.00
or Best Offer
$6.34 shipping
Rainbow Brite 1983 vintage springbok 100 piece puzzle PZL1178 - Sealed New
$99.00
or Best Offer
$6.53 shipping
11 watching
Puzz 3D Lord Of The Rings Hobbiton Sealed 369 pc 3D Wrebbit Puzzle 2004 Vintage
$49.99
or Best Offer
$15.00 shipping
Vintage Pokemon 2002 60-piece Puzzle Collectible - Gotta Catch'em All! Sealed
$29.99
or Best Offer
$6.90 shipping
Star Wars New Hope Empire Jedi Trilogy 221 Piece Mural Puzzles Complete Set of 4
$31.91
or Best Offer
$15.00 shipping
Wrebbit 3D - Game of Thrones The Red Keep 3D Jigsaw Puzzle 845 Piece New
$25.22
or Best Offer
$13.58 shipping
Puzzle 3D Lord Of The Rings Golden Hall Edoras 742 pc 3D Wrebbit Puzzle
(1)
$49.95
or Best Offer
Free shipping
HARRY POTTER 875 PIECE HOGWARTS ASTRONOMY TOWER 3D PUZZLE NEW IN BOX
(1)
$28.75
$8.00 shipping
1992 Springbok DINOTOPIA Festival of Children and Hatchlings 1000pc Puzzle NEW
(1)
$49.99
or Best Offer
$13.10 shipping
NEW Vintage SPRINGBOK Unicorn 100 Piece Puzzle SEALED (1985) 7" x 10.5" PZL4729
$14.99
or Best Offer
$7.00 shipping
Dinotopia New Springbok 1000 piece Puzzle Festival of Children and Hatchlings
$49.99
$12.99 shipping
1999 Milton Bradley/Hasbro 60 Piece Pokemon Puzzle Sealed/Unopened
$7.50
or Best Offer
$8.85 shipping
Vintage Goosebumps Glow in the Dark Jigsaw Puzzle Milton Bradley 1996 New Sealed
$31.99
or Best Offer
$12.00 shipping
New - Wrebbit Harry Potter Collection - Hagrid's Hut 3D Puzzle: 270 Pcs
(2)
$32.49
$11.80 shipping
Sandy Miller Springbok Love Thingies Puzzle Mini Circle Jigsaw VTG Dimitri 7”
$14.99
or Best Offer
$5.21 shipping
Harry Potter: Hogwarts Astronomy Tower Wrebbit 3D Jigsaw Puzzle *New
(1)
$29.97
$5.00 shipping
Sealed - Unidentified Fantasy Objects Puzzle Springbok Grand Master Series 1984
$32.50
or Best Offer
$10.00 shipping
Wrebbit 3d Puzzle Snow White 7 Dwarves 96pcs Walt Disney
$19.96
or Best Offer
$9.00 shipping
Vintage Springbok Verticalville II 2 Comic 700 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle 99% Missing 3
$24.95
or Best Offer
$7.16 shipping
Puzzle 3D Lord Of The Rings Golden Hall Edoras 742 pc 3D Wrebbit Puzzle
(1)
$23.00
or Best Offer
$9.88 shipping
WREBBIT 3D Harry Potter Diagon Alley Jigsaw Puzzle 450 Pieces New Unopened
(9)
$19.99
or Best Offer
$7.57 shipping
VTG Springbok Unicorn Puzzle YOU'RE UNIQUE 7 Inch Round *Verified Complete*
$7.95
$5.21 shipping
Vintage Springbok Puzzle Grand Master Series Unidentified Fantasy Objects 500+
$19.99
$13.25 shipping
Football Fantasy 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Springbok New
(3)
$29.99
Free shipping
Vintage 1987 Springbok Hallmark Monsters and Mystery 100 Piece Puzzle Jigsaw M8
$20.00
or Best Offer
$8.50 shipping
Wrebbit 3D - Harry Potter 3D Puzzle ‘The burrow’
(6)
$25.00
or Best Offer
$7.16 shipping

Best Selling

See All

Magic Puzzle Company The Mystic Maze Jigsaw Puzzle - BGZ111372 (1000 Pieces)
(3)
$19.99 New
$9.00 Used
USAopoly The Legend of Zelda Breath of the Wild Lynel 1000 Piece Puzzle
$69.00 New
$28.99 Used
4D Cityscape Harry Potter: Hogwarts Castle 3D Puzzle - 428 Pieces
(14)
$10.00 New
$9.00 Used
Anatolian Como Terrace 4000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle By Dominic Davison
$56.17 New
The Hobbit Classic MasterPieces 1000pcs Jigsaw Puzzle
(4)
$99.95 New
$19.99 Used
Heye Australian Habitat 1000 PC Jigsaw Puzzle Funky Zoo Marino Degano US SELLER
$29.99 New
Ceaco Glow in The Dark 550 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Kindred Spirits 24" X 18" 12 & up
(1)
$17.99 New
$16.45 Used
Ceaco James Christensen 500 PC The Candleman Cork Board Jigsaw Puzzle
$68.00 New

Motors

Clothing & Accessories

Sporting goods

Electronics

Business & Industrial

Jewelry & Watches

Collectibles & Art

Home & garden

Other categories

Fantasy Puzzles

Shop by Category

629 Results

Foil Effect Metallic 500 Piece Puzzle Girl Eagles Camels Butterflies MC Puzzle

HARRY POTTER PUZZLE 400PC "THE GREAT HALL"

1987 Springbok Hallmark Puzzle "Monsters and Mystery" 100 pcs / PZL1207 Complete

Vtg Puzzle Springbok Island Fantasy 500 Pc Sealed 18"x 24" Ocean Sailboat Palms

1982 Springbok Song Of The Unicorn Puzzle *Missing 1 Piece* Hallmark PZL4143

Vintage Springbok Carnival of Harlequin Puzzle 390 pieces COMPLETE + Poster Miro

Vintage 1977 Springbok “Verticalville” 500 Piece Puzzle - MISSING 1 PIECE

Dungeons & Dragons 300 Piece 18" x 24" Jigsaw Puzzle Yawning Portal Gencon

Vintage Round Springbok Puzzle - Five-Clawed Dragon - 390 pieces COMPLETE

Vintage Springbok 500 Piece Puzzle Song of The Unicorn Vtg 1970'S

Vintage Springbok Thingie Jigsaw Puzzle 1968 Family Portrait PZL9001 Sealed

Wrebbit 3D Puzzle Harry Potter Ford Anglia NEW Limited Edition 24 Piece Kids

Springbok Hallmark Puzzle COMPLETE At the Wee Folks Fair 1000 Piece 24x30" VTG

Red Dragonfly Foil Fantasy Bug 500 PC Puzzle Milton Bradley 2019 Metallic Effect

Harry Potter 3D puzzles lot of 2 Great Hall and Astronomy Tower Sealed No Box

Vtg Springbok Light Fantasy Puzzle 500 P 1973 USA circular Photo Art 505 Pcs!

New England Fantasy, Vintage Springbok Puzzle, 1000 pieces, 1984, complete

Springbok BUCCANEER'S DREAM 500 pc Jigsaw Puzzle PZL4414 Complete MERMAID Ocean

Vintage Springbok 500 Piece Puzzle Song of The Unicorn Vtg 1970'S

Lord of the Rings Wrebbit Hobbiton 3D Puzzle 363 pcs The Hobbit An Unexpected Jo

THE LORD of the RINGS THE TWO TOWERS ORTHANC TOWER Puzz 3D Puzzle 350 UNCOUNTED

Lord of the Rings Wrebbit Citadel of Minas Tirith 3D Puzzle 819 pcs Over 2' High

Vintage Springbok Jigsaw Puzzle LUMINESCENCE! 500+ pc Octagonal Shaped COMPLETE

Vtg 1984 Springbok 500pc octagonal shaped jigsaw puzzle Luminescence! COMPLETE

🧩🌻 NIS - Witches Gathering 500pcs Springbok Puzzle 🌻🧩

Wrebbit 3D - Harry Potter Hogwarts Great Hall 3D Jigsaw Puzzle - 850Piece Sealed

VTG Springbok Puzzle, New England Fantasy, embroidery 1000pc COMPLETE!

Vtg 1973 Jigsaw Puzzle Walt Disney's Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs Pzl-1081

SEALED 2003 Neopets 100-Piece Puzzle Lupe Warrior Hasbro MB

NEW Vintage Springbok "At the Wee Folks Fair" 1000 Piece King-Size Jigsaw Puzzle

Vtg 1979 Springbok MOUNTAINSIDE PARK Bob Martin 1000 Pc Jigsaw Puzzle

HTF Vintage 1977 Hallmark Jigsaw Puzzle Story Search for the Flying Saucer 110

Opened Wrebbit The Lord of the Rings - Golden Hall - Edoras 3D Puzzle: 445 Pcs

Fantasyland, Vintage Springbok children's puzzle, 100 pieces, complete

The Lord of the Rings Wrebbit Rohan The Two Towers Puzzle 500 pcs Perfalock

Rainbow Brite 1983 vintage springbok 100 piece puzzle PZL1178 - Sealed New

Puzz 3D Lord Of The Rings Hobbiton Sealed 369 pc 3D Wrebbit Puzzle 2004 Vintage

Vintage Pokemon 2002 60-piece Puzzle Collectible - Gotta Catch'em All! Sealed

Star Wars New Hope Empire Jedi Trilogy 221 Piece Mural Puzzles Complete Set of 4

Wrebbit 3D - Game of Thrones The Red Keep 3D Jigsaw Puzzle 845 Piece New

Puzzle 3D Lord Of The Rings Golden Hall Edoras 742 pc 3D Wrebbit Puzzle

HARRY POTTER 875 PIECE HOGWARTS ASTRONOMY TOWER 3D PUZZLE NEW IN BOX

1992 Springbok DINOTOPIA Festival of Children and Hatchlings 1000pc Puzzle NEW

NEW Vintage SPRINGBOK Unicorn 100 Piece Puzzle SEALED (1985) 7" x 10.5" PZL4729

Dinotopia New Springbok 1000 piece Puzzle Festival of Children and Hatchlings

1999 Milton Bradley/Hasbro 60 Piece Pokemon Puzzle Sealed/Unopened

Vintage Goosebumps Glow in the Dark Jigsaw Puzzle Milton Bradley 1996 New Sealed

New - Wrebbit Harry Potter Collection - Hagrid's Hut 3D Puzzle: 270 Pcs

Sandy Miller Springbok Love Thingies Puzzle Mini Circle Jigsaw VTG Dimitri 7”

Harry Potter: Hogwarts Astronomy Tower Wrebbit 3D Jigsaw Puzzle *New

Sealed - Unidentified Fantasy Objects Puzzle Springbok Grand Master Series 1984

Wrebbit 3d Puzzle Snow White 7 Dwarves 96pcs Walt Disney

Vintage Springbok Verticalville II 2 Comic 700 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle 99% Missing 3

Puzzle 3D Lord Of The Rings Golden Hall Edoras 742 pc 3D Wrebbit Puzzle

WREBBIT 3D Harry Potter Diagon Alley Jigsaw Puzzle 450 Pieces New Unopened

VTG Springbok Unicorn Puzzle YOU'RE UNIQUE 7 Inch Round *Verified Complete*

Vintage Springbok Puzzle Grand Master Series Unidentified Fantasy Objects 500+

Football Fantasy 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Springbok New

Vintage 1987 Springbok Hallmark Monsters and Mystery 100 Piece Puzzle Jigsaw M8

Wrebbit 3D - Harry Potter 3D Puzzle ‘The burrow’

Best Selling

Magic Puzzle Company The Mystic Maze Jigsaw Puzzle - BGZ111372 (1000 Pieces)

USAopoly The Legend of Zelda Breath of the Wild Lynel 1000 Piece Puzzle

4D Cityscape Harry Potter: Hogwarts Castle 3D Puzzle - 428 Pieces

Anatolian Como Terrace 4000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle By Dominic Davison

The Hobbit Classic MasterPieces 1000pcs Jigsaw Puzzle

Heye Australian Habitat 1000 PC Jigsaw Puzzle Funky Zoo Marino Degano US SELLER

Ceaco Glow in The Dark 550 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Kindred Spirits 24" X 18" 12 & up

1982 Springbok Song Of The Unicorn Puzzle Missing 1 Piece Hallmark PZL4143

VTG Springbok Unicorn Puzzle YOU'RE UNIQUE 7 Inch Round Verified Complete